Wednesday, September 16, 2009

Presentations-- Good or Bad?

When Mr. Kunkle first mentioned that everyone would have to do a presentation at some point about an article of their choice, the first thought that popped into my mind was, "Great... another speech." After only two presentations, my view has completely changed. Our class does an excellent job of reading and thinking about the essays people present; we also get involved in the article and discussion.

I have noticed that during the presentations, debates start to happen because many of these topics tend to be controversial subjects. Still, everyone stays respectful, and I think a lot of good ideas and explanations surface. I'm glad to see that our class respects each others' opinions, because without respect, I don't think the discussions would be nearly as deep.

These essays also help with critical reading. We have to analyze the information and determine our own point of view on the topic. When I read the essays I usually develop a personal stance on the topic, and in doing so, I try to think of reasons to support my stance. This helps not only understand the essay more deeply, but it also makes you challenge the writer's ideas (which may not be correct!).

In the end, I think this assignment will turn out to help everyone. It helps the presenter because they have to make a 'speech,' but it also aids the audience by creating a situation for critical thinking. I can't wait to see what new articles people will share!

6 comments:

  1. Joe this was a fantastic blog choice. REALLY ORIGINAL!!!!!~!!!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Really? Because yesterday after class you were telling me how pointless these presentations are.

    Nah, I'm just f'in. Yeah I think it's a good oppurtunity to be the center of the class and be able to shed your opinions and see how it collides with others. Good post, keep it up!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Admittedly I was kind of grumpy when I heard about this originally, but I think this is definitely one of my favorite parts about AP Comp. As you say, it really does bring everyone into the topic and everyone gets the same benefit.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I definitely agree! I love our discussions, because of exactly what you said. It's like everyone is so open--everyone gets to discuss his or her own opinion, and our whole class respects that and tries to either add on or find a way to dispute it. Great post overall--I have like the exact same opinions as you about the presentations, so it was fun to read.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I also am in support of the presentations. So far we have had interesting articles to read, which makes the presentations better. Controversial topics allow the class to start some great discussions as well.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Like those above me, I too agree with you about this. I was really nervous for these presentations at first, but now I see how interesting our discussions are and how easily we all build off of each other's ideas. Our discussions, though sometimes very serious, are thorough and respectful, which I think is really important, and I'm glad to have had the chance to participate in something like this through taking this class. Nice post, Joe!

    ReplyDelete