I'll start off by saying that I missed the last day of the movie so I have no clue if the girl ever got a cochlear implant.
Now that I said that, there was something from that movie that really got on my nerves. As the parents, they shouldn't have even questioned the thought of the cochlear implant for a second. They didn't mention any side-effects so I'm assuming their fear of the implant wasn't due to medical reasons. No, it was just plain selfishness.
Throughout the movie, the parents used the excuse, "If she gets a cochlear implant she will forget all about deaf culture and become a hearing person only." That's complete crap. Both of her parents are deaf. How can she just forget about deaf culture? She has to be able to communicate with her parents, and I'm sure the way they raise her, she will be heavily involved in the deaf community.
The ability for her to function readily with the vast majority of the world offers her so much potential. Why her parents try to deny her that astounds me.
Wednesday, October 7, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

I agree with you completely- I felt given their living situation in New York, it was necessary for Heather to get an implant. I felt like they were being way too conservative and old fashioned for the technological times these days. Once they moved to the deaf community in Maryland, it didn't seem as crazy to not have an implant because everyone could communicate via sign language.
ReplyDeleteI agree! I think that by not giving her the implant, they were holding her back from achieving everything she could in life. And I don't know if you meant to do it or not, but I really like your title! It's a good play on words and I think it adequately describes the feelings I felt while listening to the things Peter said when he completely denied even the thought of cochlear implants for his child.
ReplyDeleteI feel exactly the same way about Heather getting a cochlear implant. Like you mentioned, I highly doubt she would just become uninvolved with the deaf culture. She will still be surrounded by it. She would just have the opportunity to communicate with hearing people as well. I agree that it was selfish.
ReplyDeleteI missed the last day too! However, I know that she got the implant. So I was happy to hear that. In fact, all the members of the family got the implant except for the dad.
ReplyDeleteI totally agree with you. The father especially made me mad because he was so stubborn and wouldn't even let his mother (or whoever he had that huge arguement with) explain why coclear impants can be good. I think he was being selfish, and he cared more about himself than his daughter!
ReplyDeleteAAAHHHH!! I know dude! The parents, especially the dad, seemed so selfish. I didn't understand what the big deal was with being able to speak and use sign language. Good Post
ReplyDelete