Saturday, August 1, 2009

Response to "Talk of the Town"

I would like to start with Susan Sontag's article first. This article was extremely negative towards the U.S. government and the nation as a whole. I found it sickening that she was trying to defend the terrorists who took down the World Trade Center. Instead of calling the terrorists cowards, who, let me remind you, killed thousands of innocent Americans while they were at work, defenseless, she appoints American soldiers this title. The very same soldiers who are fighting these terrorists and protecting our freedom. I found a very interesting quote the other day that I would like to share:

"It is the Soldier, not the reporter who has given us the freedom of the press; It is the Solder, not the poet who has given us the freedom of speech; It is the Soldier, not the campus organizer who has given us freedom to demonstrate; It is the Soldier-- Who salutes the flag; Who serves beneath the flag; and whose coffin is draped by the flag, Who allows the protestor to burn the flag."

It is a very strong statement, and while it is biased, I believe that there is a lot of truth in it.

I think it was a mistake for Sontag to bring politics so heavily into her article. The whole article is basically blaming President Bush for all the problems. Sontag even goes so far as to call him a 'robotic President.' Most Conservatives reading this article will probably be turned away by her very Liberal comments. This article seems to me to be more of a campaign sponsored by Democrats than an article with any real purpose.

Have some pride in your country.

On the other hand, I found Adam Gopnik's article extremely refreshing. There were many well thought out ideas in his article. I liked how Gopnik showed all the pain and grief the parents went through. The cell phones ringing while the students' bodies were carried out really draws on emotions.

It was nice to see an opinion Pro-Gun Control that didn't want to outright ban all guns. I agree completely that no ordinary citizen should be allowed to own an automatic weapon. You can't use them to hunt; nothing good can come out of people having automatic weapons. Pistols are a touchy subject though. While people don't hunt with them, they are very effective for defense. Unfortunately it seems as if in many instances they do more harm than if they wouldn't have been used at all.

There aren't many problems with shootings with rifles and shotguns (used for hunting). The problems come in when automatics and pistols are introduced. As Gopnik stated laws are there to prevent bad things from happening. Preventing scenarios such as the Virginia Tech shooting saves both money and an unmeasurable amount of pain.

No comments:

Post a Comment