Tuesday, August 25, 2009

Skunk Dreams

I found "Skunk Dreams" to be a very frustrating and time consuming piece of literature to read. Consequently, this response may seem rather lacking in comparison to my others.

Now, before I start ripping on Louise Erdrich, one thing I would like to say is that her writing is extremely detailed and descriptive. Her words painted vivid pictures in my mind and helped me understand what she was writing about. I found multiple words to use for my vocab flashcards in her essay.

As for the rest of her essay, well let's just say, I found it rather lacking for a writer. The essay seemed to jump around from point to point, rarely making solid connections. There didn't seem to be a moral of the story or any single point that Erdrich was trying to make. The closest I could find was that she loved the openness of the west, but she began to learn to love the woods. Potentially this could represent that you can love more than one thing.

It seems as if the event with the skunk opened the door to philosophy with Erdrich. On page 338 she talks extensively about the skunk having the same dream as her that night. For the rest of the essay, Erdrich brings up topics relating to philosophy. Her seeming obsession with philosophy makes me wonder just how much of an impact that skunk had on her life.

When Erdrich moved to New England, she talks about how she missed the openness of the prairies of North Dakota. "And yet, even though I finally grew closer to these woods, on some days I still wanted to tear them from before my eyes." I feel as if her want for the openness of land somehow reflects her views; the openness reminds her of all the possibilities that are out there.

Erdrich's essay had some good points to make, but I think the way she went about it made it overly complicated. The story was hard to read and understand, and the overall message was lost to me. In the end she did make me think a little bit harder about philosophy and the unknown, but I don't think it was enough to redeem her essay.

No comments:

Post a Comment