Tuesday, October 27, 2009

Tim O'Brien -- Am I Missing Something?

So to start off, I'll admit The Things They Carried is an interesting book. It goes into depth on the different hardships the soldiers endured on their tour of Vietnam. During class everyone is constantly saying how they love the book, the newest chapter is amazing, and the like. Personally, I find The Things They Carried to be a bit of a let down.

He has several different stories dealing with the war, but the problem is the truth. I am fully aware that war is so chaotic at points that the facts are hard to get straight. But fabricating entire stories? That seems unfair to the true acheivments of soldiers during the war. His choice of making up the stories detracts from the reading for me because I am constantly asking myself, "Is this real?"

Another style of Tim O'Brien that erks me is his use of repetition. He will tell a story once. Then he moves onto another story. Then O'Brien revisits the first story, and, oftentimes repeats word for word his descriptions. He slowly goes into more detail, but I find the repetition to slow down the pace of the story.

Even with my criticisim, I still think The Things They Carried is a good book--just not as good as everyone else thinks. Now, after saying all that, I'm slightly worried about what you guys might do to me in the name of Tim O'Brien and your love for the book.

7 comments:

  1. This book is awesome, and I can't believe you don't like it. Maybe if we read a love story you would enjoy it more

    ReplyDelete
  2. It's okay that you are crazy about it! We all have different tastes. However, I think that the whole "is this the truth?" thing is a very valid reason not to like a book. I was flustered by it at first too, but now I'm starting to realize that no matter what's true and what's not, O'Brien is still managing to get his ideas, stories, and thoughts about the war out. They're in your head, and they'll affect how you think about war later on whether they're true or not.
    Just my opinion. . .
    Good post though!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Way to put your thoughts out there, Joe. While I really enjoy this book, it's nice to see that not everyone is goo-goo over this book. I think you'll bring another perspective to the discussions.

    ReplyDelete
  4. first comment should have said aren't** crazy. whoopthies. . .

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree with you on a lot of this. It is distracting that you never know if he's telling the truth or not. I feel a little better, though, after reading the chapter about that last night. Keep having a different view point, that's good! I'm not as crazy about it as everyone else is either. I still like it, but not as much as the rest of the class.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I disagree for the most part. This book is pretty bomb so far.

    ReplyDelete
  7. After reading that chapter last weekend where he was talking about how he made everything in the book up, I'd have to agree with a lot of this. It didn't bother me so much before, but now that he said that it is all I can think of-- that it isn't true.

    ReplyDelete