This essay was by far my most favorite of all. The essay brought technology and science together (not exactly a hard feat), and made for a very interesting and thought provoking read. Coincidentally, these two subjects happen to be my favorite subjects and I love learning new things about them.
My favorite quote of the essay is, "Once I was a scuba diver in the sea of words. Now I zip along the surface like a guy on a Jet Ski." This quote not only provides excellent imagery but also serves the thesis of Nicholas Carr's essay: the internet is taking away the depth of reading books and replacing it with much more, albeit shallow, information. To an extent I find this true in my own life. I used to read A LOT; now, most of my reading consists of blogs and forums online. After I finish an article online, I close out the page and find a new website or topic, leaving little time to reminisce on any thoughts or opinions that may have been building up.
I found the study done by scholars from University College London provided some very interesting insight as to what the future may hold for books. Will books start to become shorter and more full of flashy and catchy phrases, yet lacking in substance? If the internet writing style begins to move into conventional writing and books, we may eventually be faced with a world that eerily resembles that of Ray Bradbury's Fahrenheit 451.
At this point, I feel obligated to voice my opinion towards the comments made by Maryanne Wolf from Tufts University. She claims that as the internet pushes "efficiency" and "immdeicacy", we weaken the capacity for deep reading and comprehension. I don't disagree with what she is saying; in fact, scientifically, it is probably correct as explained throughout the article. The problem is that the internet is just shaping us into today's society. Yes, the internet does value speed and efficiency, but to survive in today's world, you need it. It may not be the best thing, but you need to use it to stay competitive so the internet won't be leaving anytime soon. The world is constantly evolving; the way we get information must follow the evolution and adapt.
Maryanne Wolf is also worried about losing the deep and thoughtful components of literature. While the internet may not be nearly as deep, it is definitely not a terrible abomination either. As mentioned earlier, it offers benefits such as ease of access (finding a newspaper article online from several years ago in seconds rather than looking through articles at the library) and much more information faster. In the past faster has tended to be better. Speed also typically leads to progress. Take for example the evolution of travel. At first, man had to walk everywhere. Man was isolated in a small community. Eventually man received horses and their range increased. Trading between communities increased and ideas began spreading. Then came the trains. This allowed for mass transport of people, food, and materials. And then finally we have cars and planes. I don't think many people would argue that cars are a bad thing (except for pollution), especially if they had to walk 10 miles to school/work every day.
Fredrick Winslow Taylor took a unique approach to improve efficiency in factories. By determining the most efficient way to produce each item, he increased factory output immensely. He helped change the way things were produced world wide, but he was wrong about one thing. He assured his followers that once his systems were applied to all acts of manual labor, it would create a utopia of perfect efficiency. Unfortunatley this statement is flawed. There will never be a utopia of perfect efficiency for the same reason that Communism will never completely work. People are individuals; they are not programmed like a computer. Everyone has their own thoughts and ideas. Conflicting ideas lead to disagreements. There may be the 'perfect' wage to pay factory workers, but the workers may decide that the wages are too low and go on strike, throwing off the whole system. Perfect efficiency is impossible just like a perpetual motion machine (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perpetual_motion); there will always be something preventing it.
After reading this article, I was surprised to learn about the science behind what we read and our brains. While the internet may not be encouraging the best habits, I believe that its something we are just going to have to live with. I don't believe books will entirely fade away, and the internet is just such a powerful tool that without it, today's society would crumble away.
Folks, like it or not, the internet is here to stay.
Sunday, August 30, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

This was also my favorite article, and I agreed with what you mentioned. I too think that the internet has made a vast amount of information available only a couple of clicks away. Even though it might not be as deep, it is still very useful information that in the past required a trip to the library.
ReplyDeleteYour post also brought back memories from Physics. Although a perpetual motion machine may not be possible, a perpetual motion squad definitely is.
Strong response, Joe. I really like how you take the author's words and use them to create a new argument. Much better than just a plot summary!
ReplyDelete